So I made a last minute trip to New York for the 4th of July holiday to help move my friend, D’arcy into the city and visit my friend from MSU, Will (check out my post about our dinner at Troppo). Will, while he’s a relatively “safe” eater, is a foodie as well and told me to look forward to eating the best of the best eats in New York.

Since 1970
So 4:30 a.m. comes and (surprisingly) D’arcy and I are out on the road. We packed sandwiches and some fruit the night before, so no fun lunch posts to blog. I’m terrible with directions but surprisingly, D’arcy and I arrived into New York around a mere 12 hours later. After a long drive, it was time to get some real food in our tummies! Will decided to take D’arcy and I to his favorite pizza place in New York, “Little Vincent’s” located in Huntington, Long Island.
There were a lot of cool shops on the way to Vincent’s (even just from where we parked!) but my mind was set on pizza and we didn’t bother dilly dallying or window shopping. Our stomach’s were growling and Will led us to this little pizza place place.
I was immediately surprised by the size of this place. There was a long counter where a line was already forming (good sign) with the ovens in sight. There were maybe 6 small tables and the walls had very little decor other than the cheap plastic hanging plants. Most of the tables were full, so I snagged a booth in the back while Will and D’arcy went to the counter to order.

Will & D'arcy reach the front of the line
I was waiting less than 10 minutes at the table, but the longer I sat there, the more people filled in the restaurant. Before you know it there were all sorts of people in line: families (including kids in strollers), adults, teenagers, couples, and a policeman who called me out as an “outsider,” As I’m sitting here snapping pics, he says “so you’re a tourist?” and that’s when I tell him about this awesome food blog I write…
Will bought 3 pieces for D’arcy and I to split, 2 for himself and a soda (had to stick with the NY lingo). After the fact I asked Will what the price was per slice, he said he wasn’t sure (I don’t even think it was listed anywhere?) but that it was around $14-$15 bucks.
Will brings over the pizza on white paper plates and after being up for close to 20 hours, I immediately perked up. I’m normally not a cheese only pizza person, but will assured me this was the only way to go – the classic!
I of course picked the bubble piece – ever since I was a little kid I’d always try to pick the piece with the biggest bubble – and this was the perfect slice!

Little Vincent's Pizza in Huntington, Long Island NY
I took a napkin and dabbed off some of the grease (trying to be somewhat healthy, I guess?) before I began to dig in. This pizza was “butter in my mouth” and the sauce was what made it exceptional! It was more of a sweet tomato cream sauce rather than the regular spicy sauce I’m used to.
Normally my favorite part of the pizza is the crust (I love carbs – the Italian in me) and prefer thick doughy crusts – it’s like an extra breadstick!
This crust was thin and crispy, and I was surprised how much I enjoyed it. Most of the time pizza is heavy, greasy and I feel really stuffed after, food-coma style. But after eating a piece in a half of Little Vincent’s pizza, I felt great! My stomach wasn’t turning and I didn’t resort straight back to the couch.
I’m not even a big pizza person, but if I lived in Long Island I don’t think I could pass this place without stopping in to get a slice! You could tell this pizza was baked to order with 100% natural, fresh ingredients. I was beyond satisfied with the taste and quality of Little Vincent’s pizza. The place was cozy, it was Italian owned (okay so I’m biased), the food was great with good service (not the quickest – but I can understand the high demand!) and they even gave me a free magnet. Definitely one of the top pizza places I’ve been to! If you’re in Long Island, go to Little Vincent’s Pizza!
Grade: A

Pumped.
Little Vincent’s Pizza – Since 1970
329 New York Avenue
Corner of Main Street
(631) 423-9620








